Skip to content
We use only essential cookies to keep you signed in and remember your preferences. See our Cookie Policy.
TestStop
MocksPracticeResourcesIndiaBlogPricing
Sign in
Resources › IS–LM to AD–AS › 10. Hard problems
IS–LM to AD–AS · Lesson 10 of 10

The Delhi School problems

The Delhi School asks about a fifth of this module’s questions, and most of them above Easy. They use the same models as Lessons 1 to 9, but in letters, often as sets of four to six questions on one model, and they reward setting up the model carefully more than remembering results.

← IS–LM to AD–AS moduleLesson 10 of 10 · about 50 minutes
1Money demand2IS curve3LM curve4IS–LM5Policy6AD–AS7Phillips curve8Expectations9Open economy10Hard problems
A question to hold on to
Labour demand is D(w) = 1 − w and supply S(w) = w, where w = W/P. The money wage W is set to make the labour market as close to clearing as possible, subject to W ≥ W₀. Given the price level P, what is W, what is employment, and what happens to output and prices after a monetary expansion?
Delhi School of Economics entrance, 2004Solved at the end ↓
In this guide
Lesson · about 50 minutes
  1. How these questions differ
  2. Part 1: IS–LM in letters
  3. Part 2: supply from the labour market
  4. Wage-setting and price-setting (now in the inflation module)
  5. Part 3: open-economy models
  6. The opening question, solved
  7. The lesson on one screen
  8. The Delhi School questions
01
The approach

How these questions differ

  1. Write each market’s equilibrium in letters, then substitute. Solve LM for r and put it into IS, as in Lesson 4; the multipliers fall out.
  2. For “which way” questions, differentiate and sign. Most options differ only in a sign or in which parameter is in the denominator.
  3. Check the extremes. Let a parameter go to zero or infinity and see which option gives the textbook answer (a vertical LM, a liquidity trap). Wrong options usually fail one of these checks.
02
Part 1

Part 1: IS–LM in letters

DSE 2008 · three questions on one model
Y = C + I + G, C = c(Y − T), T = τY, I = Ī − dr, money demand M̄/P̄ = aY − bi, and i = r + πe. Find the effect on income of a unit rise in G, and the effects on the real rate r of a unit rise in πe and in P.
  1. 1
    Write s = 1 − c(1 − τ) and substitute LM.
    i = (aY − M/P)/b, r = i − πe, so sY = Ī − d(aY − M/P)/b + dπe + G.
  2. 2
    Income multiplier.
    dY/dG = 1/(s + ad/b) = b/(bs + ad): the Lesson 5 fiscal multiplier.
  3. 3
    Expected inflation.
    dY/dπe = bd/(bs + ad), so di/dπe = (a/b)·dY/dπe = ad/(bs + ad) < 1 and dr/dπe = −bs/(bs + ad): the real rate falls.
  4. 4
    Price level.
    A higher P cuts M/P by M/P² per unit; it works like a monetary contraction and raises r by s(M/P²)/(bs + ad).
Answer
b/(bs + ad); a fall of bs/(bs + ad); a rise of s(M/P²)/(bs + ad). Check: with b → ∞ (a liquidity trap) the first becomes 1/s, the cross multiplier.
DSE 2004 · standard
Consumption is cY + βM/P, investment α/r, transactions demand for money λY and speculative demand μ/r. By how much does aggregate demand respond to M?
  1. 1
    LM gives 1/r.
    M/P = λY + μ/r, so 1/r = (M/P − λY)/μ.
  2. 2
    Substitute into Y = C + I + G.
    Y = cY + βM/P + (α/μ)(M/P − λY) + G.
  3. 3
    Differentiate.
    dY/dM = (β + α/μ) / (P[1 − c + αλ/μ]) = (μβ + α)/(P[μ(1 − c) + αλ]).
Answer
(μβ + α)/P[μ(1 − c) + αλ]. The β term is a Pigou effect: money also raises consumption directly.

Other questions in this part turn on one slope. In DSE 2011’s model, a more interest-sensitive money demand (m₂ more negative) means a flatter LM and a smaller rise in r when G rises, and with c₁ near 1 (a flat IS) more money barely lowers r. An endogenous money supply that rises with the interest rate flattens LM and strengthens fiscal policy (DSE 2008, 2013). With the central bank targeting the interest rate, a higher target lowers output (DSE 2020), and AD becomes vertical (DSE 2018).

03
Part 2 · Interactive

Part 2: supply from the labour market

The Delhi School likes to build the AS curve from a labour market and ask how it changes shape. The set from 2004, repeated in 2017, is the classic. Without a floor, the market clears at w = ½ whatever P is, so employment is ½ and AS is vertical at f(½). With a floor W₀ on the money wage:

The wage-floor model
W=max{W0​,P/2}N=min{21​,1−W0​/P}Y=f(N)
When P < 2W₀ the floor binds: the real wage W₀/P exceeds ½ and employment is on the demand curve, 1 − W₀/P, which rises with P.
Price level P1.6
Employment N0.375
Money wage W1
Real wage W/P0.625
0.10.20.30.40.50.60.70.511.522.533.54NPASP = 2W₀AD
The floor binds

P = 1.6 is below 2W₀ = 2, so the market-clearing money wage P/2 would be under the floor. W stays at W₀, the real wage is above ½, and firms hire only 1 − W₀/P = 0.375. More demand raises P, lowers the real wage and raises employment.

So AS slopes up at low price levels and turns vertical at P = 2W₀. With IS–LM demand, a monetary expansion raises P and does not lower output (it raises it while the floor binds), and a fiscal contraction lowers P and does not raise output. A higher floor shifts AS left (DSE 2017).

DSE 2010 used a linear technology, Y = αK + βL, with a fixed money wage. Then labour demand is all-or-nothing at W/P = β: firms hire nobody if P < W/β and as many as will work if P > W/β, when employment is labour supply −γ + δW/P, which falls as P rises. The short-run AS is vertical at low P, downward sloping in the middle, and vertical again at high P, where labour supply falls to zero.

04
Moved

Wage-setting and price-setting (now in the inflation module)

The questions on this part now sit in Lesson 12 of the inflation module, with a workbench for the four wage-setting rules. The summary below stays here because it belongs to the AD–AS story.

The general form (DSE 2012)
Pt​=Pte​(1+μ)F(ut​,At​)⟹1+πt​=(1+πte​)(1+μ)F(ut​,At​)
Wage-setting W = Pᵉ·F(u, A) with F falling in u and rising in productivity A; price-setting P = (1 + μ)W.

The natural rate is where expectations are met, π = πe: (1 + μ)F(un, A) = 1. A higher mark-up needs a lower F, so a higher un; so does higher productivity, in this set-up, since F rises with A. With F = A/u − 1, the NAIRU is u = A(1 + μ)/(2 + μ), and if A grows at γ, unemployment must grow at γ to keep inflation steady.

DSE 2018 · standard
W = Pᵉ(Z − αu), P = (1 + m)W, and each worker produces one unit, so u = 1 − Y/L. Find the aggregate supply relation.
  1. 1
    Substitute u.
    W = Pᵉ(Z − α + αY/L).
  2. 2
    Mark up.
    P = Pᵉ(1 + m)(Z − α + αY/L).
Answer
P = Pᵉ(1 + m)(Z − α + αY/L): the price level rises with output and with expected prices. This is the AS relation behind Lesson 6.

In the linear forms (DSE 2019, 2020) productivity drops out when it scales both relations equally, so it has no effect on the natural rate. If wage-setting is W/Pᵉ = Aα(1 − u)1−α while price-setting gives A/(1 + μ), a rise in A lowers unemployment (DSE 2020): only part of productivity feeds into wage claims. And with πt − πt−1 = 0.1 − 3ut, holding u at 3% adds a point of inflation every year (DSE 2021), Lesson 7’s lab.

05
Part 3

Part 3: open-economy models

DSE 2007 · standard
Two countries with a fixed rate of one. Cᵢ = 200 + 0.5(Yᵢ − Tᵢ), Iᵢ = 250, G₁ = 114, G₂ = 120, Tᵢ = 0.4Yᵢ, imports Mᵢ = 40 + mᵢYᵢ with m₁ = 0.05 and m₂ = 0.3; each country’s exports are the other’s imports. Compare outputs and the trade balance.
  1. 1
    Country 1.
    Y₁ = 200 + 0.3Y₁ + 250 + 114 + (40 + 0.3Y₂) − (40 + 0.05Y₁), so 0.75Y₁ = 564 + 0.3Y₂.
  2. 2
    Country 2.
    Y₂ = 200 + 0.3Y₂ + 250 + 120 + (40 + 0.05Y₁) − (40 + 0.3Y₂), so Y₂ = 570 + 0.05Y₁.
  3. 3
    Solve.
    0.735Y₁ = 735, so Y₁ = 1,000 and Y₂ = 620.
  4. 4
    Trade.
    Country 1 exports 40 + 186 = 226 and imports 90: a surplus.
Answer
Country 1 has the higher output and a trade surplus: its low propensity to import keeps its spending at home.

The Mundell–Fleming questions are Lesson 9’s results in letters. With a floating rate and perfect mobility, a rise in lump-sum taxes leaves GDP and the interest rate unchanged and depreciates the currency (DSE 2007); a rise in foreign income leaves output unchanged (DSE 2006); and higher government spending on imported goods changes neither output nor the interest rate (DSE 2021). In DSE 2009’s model, IS slopes down and LM is vertical in (Y, e); a higher world rate shifts IS left and LM right; and a higher price level lowers Y and raises e.

DSE 2012 built a model from pieces over four questions: the goods market as a schedule in output and the real exchange rate, whose slope depends on the Marshall–Lerner condition; an asset-market and interest-parity schedule; and how G and M move their crossing.

Read the exchange-rate definition

Lesson 9’s e is the value of the home currency, so a rise is an appreciation. Many papers instead quote the rupee price of a dollar, where a rise is a depreciation. Answers flip with the definition, so settle it, from how exports depend on it, before reading the options.

06
Solving the opening question

The opening question, solved

DSE 2004 · four questions on one model
D(w) = 1 − w, S(w) = w, W ≥ W₀. Find W and N given P, then the effect of a monetary expansion.
  1. 1
    Clearing needs w = ½.
    So W = P/2 if that is allowed; otherwise the floor: W = max{W₀, P/2}.
  2. 2
    Employment.
    If the floor binds, w = W₀/P > ½ and firms hire 1 − W₀/P; otherwise ½. N = min{½, 1 − W₀/P}.
  3. 3
    Supply at high P.
    When ½ ≤ 1 − W₀/P, supply is f(½): vertical.
  4. 4
    A monetary expansion.
    AD shifts right along a supply curve that slopes up or is vertical, so P rises and Y does not fall.
Answer
W = max{W₀, P/2}; N = min{½, 1 − W₀/P}; Y does not decrease and P increases. A fiscal contraction: Y does not increase and P falls.
Watch out for

The mistakes examiners are fishing for

  • Min against max. The wage is the larger of the floor and the clearing wage; employment is the smaller of the two quantities.
  • Real against nominal rates. With expected inflation, investment uses r and money demand uses i. The real rate falls when πe rises.
  • “Does not decrease” is not “increases”. On a vertical stretch output doesn’t move; the DSE words its options to test exactly that.
  • Exchange-rate conventions. Check whether a rise means appreciation or depreciation.
07
Revise

The lesson on one screen

The lesson on one screen
Method
Equilibria in letters; substitute LM into IS; differentiate and sign; test the extremes.
Fiscal multiplier
b/(bs + ad) with money demand aY − bi and investment −dr.
Expected inflation
Raises Y and i, lowers the real rate.
Wage floor
W = max{W₀, P/2}, N = min{½, 1 − W₀/P}: AS rises, then vertical.
WS–PS
P = Pᵉ(1 + μ)F(u, A); natural rate where (1 + μ)F = 1.
Open economy
Leakages in the denominator; Mundell–Fleming results in letters; read the definition of e.
08
Real questions

The Delhi School questions

Part 1 · from Lessons 1 and 2 and 3 and 4 and 5

IS–LM in letters

Multipliers and comparative statics with parameters instead of numbers, expected inflation, and interest-rate targeting.

31 questionsPractise →
Part 2 · from Lesson 6

Aggregate supply from the labour market

Supply curves built from labour demand and supply, wage floors, fixed money wages, and shocks to AD and AS together.

22 questionsPractise →
Part 3 · from Lesson 9

Open-economy models

Mundell–Fleming under both regimes, two-country multipliers, interest parity and the Marshall–Lerner condition.

21 questionsPractise →
All 74 DSE questions, moderate before hard within each part: practise the full set →

✦These are questions from the TestStop bank. A free account answers 10 a day, each with its worked solution; All-Access opens every set with no daily limit.

← Lesson 9The open economy: Mundell–Fleming

Read next

All resources →
MacroeconomicsIS–LM to AD–AS, from zero to exam levelA module that builds the short-run macro model one curve at a time: the demand for money, the IS and LM curves, policy, aggregate demand and supply, the Phillips curve, expectations and the open economy, each with interactives and graded past-paper sets.Module · 450 minMacroeconomicsMacroeconomics 9: the Delhi School problemsThe DSE's harder questions on the module: two-class demand models, open-economy multipliers, the money multiplier and choice over time.Complete guide · 45 minStatisticsProbability 9: the hard problemsThe Delhi School's hardest probability questions by technique: first-step analysis, contests, Markov chains and random walks, and optimal stopping, with all 114 DSE questions above the easy level.Complete guide · 50 min